Navigating TCFD Challenges for Asset Managers

The Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) has positioned itself as an indispensable framework for the assessment of climate-related risks and opportunities within the financial sector. As asset managers play a pivotal role in managing trillions of dollars in investments, they have a significant responsibility to align their disclosure obligations with the TCFD recommendations. However, this transition is not without its challenges.

Enhancing Data Quality and Accessibility

One of the primary challenges for asset managers is the availability and quality of climate-related data. Gathering reliable and consistent information on greenhouse gas emissions, climate scenarios, and physical and transition risks can be complex, as it often requires collaboration with investee companies. The scarcity of data is an industry-wide challenge, with a mere 50% of asset owners and 30% of asset managers reporting having access to comprehensive climate data according to the Principles for Responsible Investment.

To overcome data limitations, asset managers need to engage with data providers, investee companies, and industry peers to enhance the quality and availability of climate-related data. Collaboration platforms such as the Climate Disclosure Standards Board (CDSB) and the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) can facilitate the standardisation of climate-related reporting. The adoption of artificial intelligence and machine learning across the industry may be a significant turning point to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of data analysis.

Engagement to Enhance Disclosures

Fulfilling TCFD-aligned disclosure obligations demands a nuanced approach to reporting, where transparency is balanced against the need to protect sensitive information. This balance is challenging, as evidenced by PwC analysis finding that 57% of asset managers express concerns over competitive disadvantages linked to climate risk disclosure.

Leveraging established reporting frameworks such as the GRI and SASB can guide asset managers in structuring their climate-related disclosures. Engaging with a broad spectrum of stakeholders ensures that reporting practices are aligned with external expectations and regulatory requirements, thereby enhancing the quality and relevance of disclosures.

Climate Risk Integration into Investment Processes

Still, a major hurdle for asset managers is the incorporation of climate risks into their investment decision-making frameworks. With Global Reporting Initiative finding that only 44% of asset managers are currently integrating climate risk into their processes, there is a clear need for a paradigm shift. Asset managers can overcome this by adopting a risk-based disclosure approach, underpinned by a focus on dynamic materiality.

Enhancing team competencies through targeted training and the recruitment of climate experts can facilitate this integration. Collaborative initiatives with organisations like the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) offer valuable insights and best practices for embedding climate considerations into investment strategies effectively.

Strategic Engagement for Opportunities

With sustainable funds reaching record levels in recent years according to data from Morningstar, investor interest in environmentally sustainable investments is unmistakable. Asset managers have a crucial role in educating investors about the significance of climate-related disclosures and their impact on investment performance. Engagement strategies, harnessing targeted communications and strategic insights will be key to not only making investors aware of challenges but also identifying the real opportunities of shifting investment toward net-zero transitions.

As global awareness of climate-related risks continues to grow, asset managers face significant challenges in meeting TCFD-aligned disclosure obligations. Overcoming these challenges requires a multi-faceted approach, including improving data availability and quality, integrating climate risks into investment processes, enhancing reporting and disclosures, and educating and engaging investors. By navigating these hurdles, asset managers can not only fulfill their disclosure obligations but also contribute to financial stability, promote sustainable investments, and drive the transition to a low-carbon economy.

At Pimlico Strategy & Insights, we produce sustainability insights and strategies that deliver.

Contact us for a consultation today!